As the voice of snow-sculpting Frozen star Elsa, Idina Menzel has winter bona fides for days—look no further than her playful turns on the Olaf’s Frozen Adventure soundtrack. But the Broadway star’s aptitude for interpreting holiday classics is equally impressive. The 2019 collection Christmas: A Season of Love has crisp, jazzy takes on standards such as “Sleigh Ride,” all buoyed by her sparkly, jubilant mezzo-soprano, while more meditative songs (a melancholy take on Joni Mitchell’s “River,” the reverential “Silent Night”) honor seasonal fare’s emotional nuance.