I probably should have kept on singing your favorite song

When you told me please keep doing what you're doing

and I'll sing along

I probably should have reached out my hand and put it into yours

But those butterflies seem to always migrate right into my core

And I probably shouldn't be out here again

Counting leaves as they fall and talking to the wind

And I probably should have been the one to know

But where am I supposed to go, if that girl's where I called home

And I swear I would have done things a little differently

, probably... probably

I probably should have cooled my temper

And just went to bed, but I said some things that night

I hope you know I never meant

I probably should have showed you that night that letter I penned

But all these mistakes came flooding back when you walked in with him

And I probably shouldn't be out here again

Counting leaves as they fall and talking to the wind

And I probably should have been the one to know

But where am I supposed to go, if that girl's where I called home

I swear I would have done things a little differently,

Probably... probably

And I probably shouldn't be writing again about you

Singing my heart out to the wind

And I probably should have been the one to know

But where am I supposed to go, if that girl's where I called home

I swear I would have done things a little differently,

Probably... probably

I probably should have said a little sooner, I love you too

Cause you know I'll never love anyone quite like you