The Story of Buddy the ElfMark Hamill, Gilbert Gottfriedm, Steve Higgins, Rachel Ramras, Kate Micucci, Fred Armisenm, Ed Asner, Rachel Bloom, Max Charles, Larry Dorf, Kevin Shinick, Jim Parsonsm & Rachael MacFarlane
A Christmas Song (Reprise)Rachel Ramras, Rachel Bloom, Max Charles, Larry Dorf, Mark Hamill, Rachael MacFarlane, Kevin Shinick, Kate Micucci & Jim Parsons