You were just a stranger. And I couldn’t fight the curiosity. I was tempted by the danger. And I craved to know so I sunk in my teeth.

And now bitterness is all I taste and the salt from the tears rolling down my face. Was it worth it all cause now I’m trapped here in this place?

Chorus: And when I see you I don’t see you like a stranger anymore. When I see you I can’t look at you the way I did before. I wish I could turn back time to when you were just a mystery. Cause when I see you all I see is all our history. I see you and me. Oh I wish you were a stranger. Oh I wish you were a stranger.

I used to sit and wonder how it would feel to kiss your lips and hold you in my arms. I was the sun and you were thunder; the thief of my heart disguised in perfect charm.

We lost all control and jumped in way too deep. You got out of the cold and left me in to freeze and now there’s no one around and I’m drowning in this misery.

(Chorus)

And we heard that same old song about two becoming one. It must have played a thousand times. And I thought I saw it all but I guess it’s possible I misread the signs.

(Chorus)