Looking through the moonlight baby, and what do I see
Reflections of the times we had, and how it used to be
Two lovers that were looked as one, as one looked to be loved
A romance that would take its cause as God looked me from above
But carried like the moonlight, gave it all to you
Expecting in return a love so new and true
You cheated, and you lied your way right from the start
So don't expect the place to be right in my heart
Thief of hearts, you said you'd never let me go
You broke my heart, you promised me you'd never leave me from the start
And all the dreams I had for you went much too far
You're a thief of hearts
Remembering the moments we had, how could they slip away
You promised me a love so true, it had to end this way
I can't imagine you'd be so cruel to play me like a game
It seems the love I thought we had could never be the same
But oh, oh how I loved you so
With words, I tried to let you know
Now it's time for me to make a brand-new start
The scars you left behind are hurting in my heart
Thief of hearts, you said you'd never let me go
You broke my heart, you promised me you'd never leave me from the start
And all the dreams I had for you went much too far
You're a thief of hearts
Thief of hearts, you said you'd never let me go
You broke my heart, you promised me you'd never leave me from the start
And all the dreams I had for you went much too far
You're a thief of hearts
Caring like a fool, I gave it all to you
Expecting in return a love so new and true
You cheated, and you lied your way right from the start
So don't expect the place to be right in my heart
Thief of hearts (why did you have to leave? You said you'd never leave)
You broke my heart (why must you have to leave?)
You promised me you'd never leave me from the start (why did you have to leave? Oh baby, tell me please)
Went much too far (you said you'd never leave)
You're a thief of hearts
Thief of hearts (why? Tell me why?)
You broke my heart
From the start (why? Oh, why? Tell me why?)
Went much too far
You're a thief of hearts
