Riding in your passenger seat

with your right hand on my thigh

I can feel you looking over at me

here come the butterflies

Going steady then you took a turn

heading down a dead end street

you're not a good sport, cut the dinner short

but at least you'll still treat

You were a gentleman but now I'm questioning

Was it genuine or was I being played?

There's no way to win cause I'm overthinking

what could've been if you would've stayed

a little longer babe

Mr. Emotionally unavailable

You're just into yourself

Mr. irreplaceable, I put you on a pedestal

You're no good for my health

Oh Mr. E

You're a mystery

Verse 2:

Back in your jeep at least you opened up my door

Surprised you even made the time for me

Your schedule’s never flexible

Gym, work, and therapy

We’ve been down this same old road

How are we still lost?

Silly me thinking that you’d change

Guess some things stay unsolved

Don’t wanna impose

You keep me on my toes

And god only knows

What your move will be

Are we more than friends

Or is that in my head

Tell me what could’ve been if you clued me in

To what you’re really thinking

Mr. Emotionally unavailable

You're just into yourself

Mr. irreplaceable, I put you on a pedestal

You're no good for my health

Oh Mr. E

You're a mystery

Oh Mr. E

You're a mystery

Are you too good for me?