Thinking back to how it started
Picked you up at your apartment
Nothing planned, but we were walking
Up and down 5th
Nothing like it
You would tell me everything
Tipsy on the 2 train
Thinking things won't ever change
Now, when I look back
It's nothing like that
'Cause you and I
We lost the time
Spring into the fall
I don't know why
There was no goodbye
With the writing on the wall
I left you
Somewhere in New York
You wanted me to stay
If I came back
Knocking on your door
Would it be the same
I left you somewhere in New York
On West 13th
The after-hour diner where we fell asleep
Do you still stumble in and think of me
Or do you just bring somebody else, mm
'Cause you and I
We lost the time
Spring into the fall
I don't know why
There was no goodbye
With the writing on the wall
I left you
Somewhere in New York
You wanted me to stay
If I came back
Knocking on your door (Knocking on your door)
Would it be the same (It wouldn't be the same)
I left you
Somewhere in New York (New York)
You wanted me to stay (You wanted me to stay)
If I came back
Knocking on your door (Evermore)
Would it be the same (Would it be the same)
I left you somewhere in New York
