I spent two hours getting ready with my makeup and my hair
My best friend Amy helped me pick out what to wear
I practiced what to say, I practiced what to do
But it all went out the window when I met you
I wish you weren't so pretty wish you weren't so sweet
I wish he didn't need you like he doesn't need me
I wish I hated you just like I wanted to
But you turned out to be so pretty
Ya know, you being nice to me only makes it worse
This killing me with kindness it's a blessing and a curse
I could've used a cold shoulder a pretentious "he's mine" grin
Just to prove to me that you're no good for him
I wish you weren't so pretty wish you weren't so sweet
I wish he didn't need you like he doesn't need me
I wish I hated you just like I wanted to
But you turned out to be so pretty
I might be bein' ugly
To even tell you this
But I wish I didn't have to wish
You weren't so pretty you weren't so sweet
He didn't need you like he doesn't need me
I wish I hated you just like I wanted to
But you turned out to be so pretty
